A Conversation with Mark Bryant...Since graduating
from law school in 1973, Mark Bryant has practiced law in his
hometown. That includes 13 years as McCracken commonwealth attorney
and, since 1990, being the founding partner with former assistant
prosecutor Will Kautz of what has become one of the region’s largest
law firms, located across the street from the courthouse. Bryant
recently discussed influences in his professional life, and his
priorities away from the courtroom and office, with Christopher Ash.
The public remembers you as a prosecutor – 13 years. Now, in
private practice, you seem to be doing everything.
We have really expanded. I probably would never have left the
commonwealth attorney’s office. I loved being a prosecutor, I thought
I could really help the public, and I did. But I also knew I had three
kids who were going to go to college, and I couldn’t afford to pay for
them to go to college staying over there on the state payroll. So I
left and I came here.
Since then we have gotten into so many just fabulous, fascinating
areas. I’ve learned so much, and I’ve also learned the public sector
isn’t the only place you can help people. I’ve been able to help so
many people, people who are going through some terrible times. Just
yesterday I had a case in Louisville. Some poor man burned to death as
a result of a defective transformer on a portable telephone. We filed
a lawsuit against the company. It won’t make him come back, but it at
least lets the family know the company had to pay for what happened.
(He motions toward a tire, wrapped in plastic, sitting in his office.)
That tire right there. That’s a case I’ve got against a company
that I filed a lawsuit against. Some man was driving that tire; it was
a brand new tire. As he was driving down the road the air came out of
that tire, and he’s now a paraplegic.
The God-given talent I have to practice law and hopefully say the
right words – it really does help a lot of people. The rich people,
they can always hire a lawyer because they’ve got money, but the
working class people taking on a corporation, there is no way they can
do that. I could go out and practice corporate law, but I don’t want
to.
When you went out on your own in private practice, did you envision
it becoming what it is today? Did you have a grand scheme?
When Will and I went out – we left the courthouse in January 1990 –
we didn’t have a single client. I just knew I didn’t want to do
corporate work. In the beginning I handled a whole lot of criminal
cases, because I knew how to do it.
I had a case that really, really bothered me. A man had confessed
to murder and they had all the goods on the guy. I made a motion for
the court to suppress the confession, and the court suppressed the
confession. But they still had my client with the shotgun in his
hands, and the home was on fire and there was a guy in there whom had
been shot and burned. One of the neighbors saw my client running out
of there. My job was to take the case to trial. I offered to plead him
guilty to manslaughter and take 15 years, the prosecutors wouldn’t do
that. So I went to trial, and the defendant was found not guilty. That
affected me, because my job was to defend this man, and I did defend
him.
So I started getting away from criminal defense work. Will was my
chief assistant for years and is a fantastic trial lawyer, and he
loves criminal defense work – that’s what he did before he worked for
me as my first assistant.
I started getting into product liability, and automobile accidents.
Then this case came up against Union Carbide, and I filed that
multi-billion dollar lawsuit that finally last year was dismissed, and
we’re in the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals with that right now.
In February of 2003, I got a call from a guy who was in Tamaroa,
Ill., who knew me – I had done some work for him years ago. He said
we’ve had this train derailment up here and nobody knows what to do,
will you come up here and talk to us. I drove to Tamaroa and met with
about eight people in a trailer. Snow was a foot deep that night. They
evacuated the community up there because of these chemicals that
derailed.
Those people let everybody else in town know I was interested, and
two nights later we had 500 people in a town meeting at Tamaroa. We
ended up filing a lawsuit against the Canadian National Railroad, and
we have been certified as class action. We have been to the court of
appeals in Illinois twice, now we’re in the Supreme Court. The
railroad’s fighting us every way. But we keep getting favorable
rulings out of the circuit court and look like we’re going to have a
trial scheduled in the case next summer or fall. Now we have some 600
clients, but with it being certified class action we could have more
than a thousand clients. I’ve had cases out on the river, I’ve crawled
around on barges. Years ago, when a coal mine exploded, Pyro hired
Kautz and me to represent them in U.S. District Court. Kautz and I
wound up down in an underground coal mine – the scariest thing I’ve
ever been through in my life. We’ve had airplane crashes. … No two
cases are alike. Every single day you come to the office and there’s
something fascinating about to happen.
The transition from prosecutor to advocate – what reactions have
you seen from the community? Doctors whom you are around, did you
notice hostility?
No. I represent a lot of physicians personally, and I don’t sue
doctors for medical malpractice. In Paducah, I don’t know of anybody
who handles "med-mal" cases. First place, everyone makes mistakes.
Secondly, so many of the physicians are friends of mine, but on
personal-injury cases if someone has gotten badly hurt I have to go
take a doctor’s deposition, so I don’t want them mad at me.
As a boy, were you a good public speaker?
No, I was scared to death. When I was at Tilghman High School I was
in speech class, and I got up to give my speech. The whole class was
sitting in there, it was in the auditorium at Tilghman. I stood up and
I started speaking, and I was doing quite well. Then the door opened,
and when it did I absolutely lost it. … I didn’t like that and wanted
to do better. I went to Boys State and I ran for office. When I did I
had to make some speeches.
What really got me where I could speak publicly was just trying so
many cases. It wasn’t at all unusual to try 20 or 30 cases a year I
was prosecuting, plus evidentiary hearings and such. You just get
accustomed to being around people and sense what they’re interested in
hearing. Trying lawsuits in my opinion is the best part of practicing
law, but unfortunately in private practice you don’t get to try near
as many as in public office, because so many cases are settled.
Albert Jones (Bryant’s predecessor as commonwealth attorney, who
had hired Bryant as an assistant and later practiced law with Bryant
and Kautz) not only is a first cousin but a mentor. Albert taught me
so very much that I use every single day.